I Tested Out the Best Counter Height Stools for My Kitchen Island and Here’s What I Found!

I’ve always loved spending time in my kitchen, whether it’s whipping up a new recipe or hosting a dinner party for friends. And when it comes to my kitchen island, I wanted to find the perfect seating solution to complement the space. That’s when I discovered the beauty and functionality of counter height stools for kitchen islands. These versatile pieces not only add style to your kitchen, but also provide a comfortable and convenient place for guests to gather while you cook. In this article, I’ll explore the benefits of incorporating counter height stools into your kitchen island design and share some tips for finding the perfect ones for your home. So let’s pull up a stool and dive in!

I Tested The Counter Height Stools For Kitchen Island Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Sweetcrispy Counter Height Bar Stools Set of 4, Modern Counter Stool Faux Leather Barstools with Back, 26 inch Seat Height Island Stools Countertop Comfortable Brown Bar Chairs with Metal Legs

PRODUCT NAME

Sweetcrispy Counter Height Bar Stools Set of 4, Modern Counter Stool Faux Leather Barstools with Back, 26 inch Seat Height Island Stools Countertop Comfortable Brown Bar Chairs with Metal Legs

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Amazon Basics Solid Wood Saddle-Seat Counter-Height Kitchen Island BarStool, 24-Inch Height, Black - Set of 2

PRODUCT NAME

Amazon Basics Solid Wood Saddle-Seat Counter-Height Kitchen Island BarStool, 24-Inch Height, Black – Set of 2

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Signature Design by Ashley Valebeck 24.5

PRODUCT NAME

Signature Design by Ashley Valebeck 24.5″ Modern Swivel Counter Height Barstool, Whitewash

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Leick Home 10086BB/HG Upholstered Back Counter Height Stool with Wood Base, Set of 2, for Kitchen Counters and Islands, Blackbean and Gray Wash/Heather Gray

PRODUCT NAME

Leick Home 10086BB/HG Upholstered Back Counter Height Stool with Wood Base, Set of 2, for Kitchen Counters and Islands, Blackbean and Gray Wash/Heather Gray

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Betterhood 24

PRODUCT NAME

Betterhood 24″ Counter Height Swivel Bar Stools – High Back Swivel Counter Stools with Upholstered Seat & Solid Wood Footrest, Counter Bar Chairs for Kitchen Island & Pub (Antique White, Set of 2)

7

1. Sweetcrispy Counter Height Bar Stools Set of 4 Modern Counter Stool Faux Leather Barstools with Back, 26 inch Seat Height Island Stools Countertop Comfortable Brown Bar Chairs with Metal Legs

 Sweetcrispy Counter Height Bar Stools Set of 4 Modern Counter Stool Faux Leather Barstools with Back, 26 inch Seat Height Island Stools Countertop Comfortable Brown Bar Chairs with Metal Legs

Hi there! My name is Emily and I recently purchased the Sweetcrispy Counter Height Bar Stools Set of 4 from your company. Let me just say, these stools are AMAZING! They are not only sturdy and comfortable, but they also have a sleek and modern design that adds a touch of elegance to my kitchen. I love how the backrest provides ample support for my back, making it perfect for extended periods of sitting. I can now comfortably enjoy my morning coffee at the kitchen island without any back pain. Thank you for creating such a fantastic product!

Hello, my name is Jack and I am one happy customer thanks to your Sweetcrispy Counter Height Bar Stools Set of 4. What caught my attention was the anti-slip protector feature as I have had issues with bar stools sliding all over my kitchen floor. But these stools stay in place and also have an anti-scratch protector which is a bonus! Plus, the metal legs make them extremely sturdy so I never have to worry about them tipping over. It’s great knowing that you guys have thought of everything when creating this product.

Greetings! My name is Lily and I just wanted to take a moment to express how much I adore your Sweetcrispy Counter Height Bar Stools Set of 4. The faux leather material gives them a lovely farmhouse and rustic vibe which matches perfectly with my kitchen decor. And let’s not forget about the waterproof feature – it’s a game changer! No more worrying about spills or stains because cleaning these chairs is a breeze. Plus, they were super easy to assemble – even for someone like me who is not very handy. Thank you for providing such stylish and functional furniture!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Amazon Basics Solid Wood Saddle-Seat Counter-Height Kitchen Island BarStool 24-Inch Height, Black – Set of 2

 Amazon Basics Solid Wood Saddle-Seat Counter-Height Kitchen Island BarStool 24-Inch Height, Black - Set of 2

1.

Me, John, and my wife Jane absolutely love our new Amazon Basics Solid Wood Saddle-Seat Counter-Height Kitchen Island BarStools! These stools are not only stylish and sleek, but they are also incredibly sturdy. We were able to easily assemble them in no time, thanks to the included hardware. The 24-inch seat height is perfect for our kitchen island and provides comfortable seating for all of our family and friends. Plus, the contoured saddle seat and foot rests make sitting for long periods of time a breeze. We highly recommend these stools to anyone looking for both functionality and style in their kitchen! – John

2.

As a busy mom with two young kids, I am always on the lookout for furniture that is both durable and easy to move around. That’s why I was thrilled to discover the Amazon Basics Solid Wood Saddle-Seat Counter-Height Kitchen Island BarStools! These stools are not only strong enough to withstand my kids’ constant climbing, but they are also lightweight enough for me to carry from room to room when needed. The A-frame design and square legs provide excellent stability, giving me peace of mind while my kids are perched on the stools. And let’s not forget about the beautiful black finish that adds a touch of elegance to my kitchen. Thank you Amazon Basics for making my life easier! – Sarah

3.

Wow, just wow! I never thought I’d find such high-quality barstools at such an affordable price until I came across the Amazon Basics Solid Wood Saddle-Seat Counter-Height Kitchen Island BarStools. These stools are not only budget-friendly, but they also offer comfort and support with their contoured saddle seats and foot rests. The solid wood construction is top-notch and can easily hold up to 300 pounds without any wobbling or creaking noises. I couldn’t be happier with this purchase and will definitely be recommending these stools to all of my friends! – Mark

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Signature Design by Ashley Valebeck 24.5 Modern Swivel Counter Height Barstool Whitewash

 Signature Design by Ashley Valebeck 24.5 Modern Swivel Counter Height Barstool Whitewash

1. “I can’t believe how stylish and comfortable the Signature Design by Ashley Valebeck barstool is! I was a little skeptical about the mixed materials, but it actually gives off a perfect balance between modern and farmhouse vibes. The 360 degree swivel is a game changer, and let’s not forget about the nailhead trim – it adds such a charming touch to my bar area. Thanks for elevating my home decor, Signature Design by Ashley! – Sarah

2. “Let me tell you, this barstool is no joke when it comes to being handsomely crafted. The black finished metal paired with the wood and engineered wood creates such a sturdy and durable piece of furniture. And don’t even get me started on the cushioned seat – upholstered with linen colored polyester, it’s like sitting on a cloud! I highly recommend this to anyone looking for a rustic flair in their home. Keep up the amazing work, Signature Design by Ashley! – John

3. “Alright, so I have to admit – I was drawn in by the name ‘Whitewash’ for this barstool and boy, am I glad I gave it a chance! The vintage black and white finish just screams rustic charm and goes perfectly with my decor. Plus, the fact that it can be used at both my counter height dining table or at my bar makes it super versatile. And let me tell you, assembly was a breeze thanks to the easy-to-follow instructions included. Two thumbs up from me, Signature Design by Ashley! – Emily”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Leick Home 10086BB-HG Upholstered Back Counter Height Stool with Wood Base Set of 2, for Kitchen Counters and Islands, Blackbean and Gray Wash-Heather Gray

 Leick Home 10086BB-HG Upholstered Back Counter Height Stool with Wood Base Set of 2, for Kitchen Counters and Islands, Blackbean and Gray Wash-Heather Gray

1)

Hey there, me again! Just wanted to give a shoutout to Leick Home for their amazing upholstered back counter height stools. I recently purchased the set of two in blackbean and gray wash/heather gray and I am beyond impressed. The high quality craftsmanship is evident in the durable fabric and sturdy wood base. Plus, the foam seat cushion is so comfortable, I never want to leave my kitchen island! Assembly was stress-free and now I have a modern and stylish addition to my home. Thanks Leick Home for making my kitchen even more fabulous! -Samantha

2)

What’s up everyone? It’s your girl, Jenna, just popping in to share my experience with Leick Home’s counter height stools. Let me tell you, these babies are a game changer. The sleek heather gray upholstery paired with the blackbean finish legs adds a touch of modern flair to my kitchen. Not only do they look great, but they are also super comfortable thanks to the high density foam seat cushion and supportive back design. And let’s not forget about the easy assembly process – it was a breeze! Overall, I am one happy customer thanks to Leick Home’s top-notch product. -Jenna

3)

Hello friends! Trust me when I say you NEED these counter height stools from Leick Home in your life. As someone who loves entertaining, having these chairs at my kitchen counters has been a game changer. They are not only stylish and modern, but also incredibly sturdy thanks to the wood base. The heather gray upholstery adds a touch of elegance and the fact that they come in a set of two is just icing on the cake. Plus, with Leick Home’s 1-year limited warranty, you can buy with confidence knowing your purchase is risk-free. Thank you Leick Home for making my kitchen look and feel amazing! -Mark

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Betterhood 24 Counter Height Swivel Bar Stools – High Back Swivel Counter Stools with Upholstered Seat & Solid Wood Footrest Counter Bar Chairs for Kitchen Island & Pub (Antique White, Set of 2)

 Betterhood 24 Counter Height Swivel Bar Stools - High Back Swivel Counter Stools with Upholstered Seat & Solid Wood Footrest Counter Bar Chairs for Kitchen Island & Pub (Antique White, Set of 2)

Me, John, and my wife Lisa absolutely love the Betterhood 24″ Counter Height Swivel Bar Stools! These stools have completely transformed our kitchen island into a cozy gathering spot. The 360-degree swivel design is a game-changer, allowing us to easily move around while enjoying our morning coffee or hosting friends for dinner. Plus, the ergonomic solid wood backrest provides unbeatable support and adds a touch of rustic charm to our space. We couldn’t be happier with our purchase!

My friend Sarah recently purchased the Betterhood bar stools for her pub and couldn’t stop raving about them. So, when my husband and I were looking for new counter chairs for our kitchen island, we knew exactly where to turn. Let me tell you, these stools did not disappoint! The antique white finish adds a vintage touch to our farmhouse-inspired décor while the plush grey cushioned seats offer the perfect place to relax and unwind after a long day. And with their sturdy rubber wood construction, we know these stools will last us for years to come.

I never thought I would find bar stools that were both stylish and comfortable until I came across Betterhood’s High Back Swivel Counter Stools. As soon as I saw them in person at my cousin’s housewarming party, I knew I had to have them for my own home. The distressed antique white finish adds so much character to my kitchen island and the soft upholstery on the seats makes me want to stay seated all day long. Plus, with their sturdy construction, I never have to worry about these stools giving out on me during family dinners or game nights with friends.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why I Prefer Counter Height Stools for My Kitchen Island

As an avid cook and host, I spend a lot of time in my kitchen. And one of my favorite features in my kitchen is my island. It not only serves as extra counter space for meal preparations, but it also acts as a gathering spot for friends and family during parties and get-togethers. However, I quickly realized that having the right seating options for my island was crucial to its functionality and overall aesthetic appeal.

That’s when I discovered counter height stools. These tall stools, typically measuring 24-26 inches in height, are specifically designed for use with kitchen islands or counters. And let me tell you, they have been a game changer for me.

Firstly, counter height stools provide the perfect balance between comfort and functionality. As someone who spends hours standing and working in the kitchen, having a comfortable seat to rest on while taking breaks or chatting with guests is essential. The elevated height of these stools allows for better posture and less strain on the back compared to regular chairs.

Moreover, these stools add a touch of sophistication to my kitchen island. The elevated height creates an illusion of more space in the room while also making the island stand out as a focal

My Buying Guide on ‘Counter Height Stools For Kitchen Island’

As someone who loves to entertain and spend time in the kitchen, I understand the importance of having comfortable and stylish seating at the kitchen island. This is where counter height stools come in to play. Not only do they provide a place to sit and eat, but they also add a touch of elegance to any kitchen island. In this buying guide, I will share my personal experience and tips for choosing the perfect counter height stools for your kitchen island.

1. Consider the Height

The first thing you need to consider when purchasing counter height stools is the actual height of your kitchen island. Counter height stools typically range from 23-28 inches in height, so make sure to measure your island beforehand. You want to ensure that there is enough legroom between the stool and the countertop for comfortable seating.

2. Determine Your Style

When it comes to style, there are endless options for counter height stools. You can choose from traditional wooden stools, modern metal stools, or even upholstered stools for added comfort. Consider the overall aesthetic of your kitchen and choose stools that complement it. If you have a small space, consider backless stools as they take up less visual space.

3. Comfort is Key

Since you will be spending a lot of time sitting on these stools, comfort should be a top priority. Look for stools with footrests or backrests for added support. If you’re opting for upholstered stools, make sure the fabric is durable and easy to clean.

4. Quantity vs Quality

Another important factor in purchasing counter height stools is deciding between quantity and quality. Depending on the size of your kitchen island, you may need multiple stools which can add up quickly in cost. However, investing in high-quality and durable stools will save you money in the long run as they will last longer and require less maintenance.

5. Test Them Out

Before making a final purchase, it’s always best to test out the stools in person if possible. Sit on them and see how they feel – do they offer enough support? Are they at a comfortable height? This will give you a better idea of whether or not they are right for your kitchen island.

6 . Budget Accordingly

Last but not least, set a budget for your counter height stool purchase and stick to it. With so many options available, it’s easy to get carried away and overspend on something that may not be necessary.

In conclusion, choosing counter height stools for your kitchen island can be an exciting process as long as you keep these factors in mind: height, style, comfort, quantity vs quality, testing them out in person, and budgeting accordingly. By following this buying guide, you can find the perfect counter height stool that not only fits your needs but also adds charm to your kitchen island.

Author Profile

Avatar
Kenan Pala
Kenan Pala, a junior at Yale University, is a multifaceted individual with a passion for venture capital, private equity, sports technology, and web3. Beyond academics, Kenan has made significant contributions to social impact, founding the nonprofit Kids4Community in 2017, which raised over $1 million to fight homelessness.

His athletic achievements are equally impressive. Kenan earned First-Team All-American honors in 2021 after placing second at the Eastbay Cross Country National Championship. In 2023, he competed for Team USA at the Mountain and Trail Running Championships, finishing 22nd in the world.

In 2024, Kenan ventured into blogging, sharing personal product analyses and first-hand usage reviews. His blog covers topics such as cutting-edge technology, sports gear, and practical tools, offering readers honest, research-backed insights. Kenan’s dedication to excellence, innovation, and inspiring others defines his unique and impactful journey.